A significant controversy has emerged following India pacer Akash Deep’s dismissal of England’s Joe Root during the Edgbaston Test. Akash, who stepped in for Jasprit Bumrah, delivered a remarkable performance in the second innings, securing two crucial wickets. His delivery to Joe Root, a key player for England, was particularly noteworthy and left the cricket community in awe. However, the dismissal has sparked debate over its legality. The incident occurred as England ended Day 4 with three wickets down for 72 runs. Akash’s delivery to Root was initially ruled out by the umpire, but commentators and fans have since questioned its legitimacy. Former England cricketer Alison Mitchell, commentating on BBC TMS, highlighted that Akash’s back foot appeared to land outside the return crease by about two inches, which should have been deemed illegal according to MCC Law 21.5.1. This law stipulates that a bowler’s back foot must not touch or cross the return crease during delivery. Despite these claims, former India coach Ravi Shastri defended Akash’s delivery, arguing that since his foot landed inside the return crease, it was fair. The debate has divided opinions among cricket enthusiasts and experts alike. Joe Root’s performance in the Birmingham Test was less than stellar. In the first innings, he managed only 22 runs off 46 balls, and in the second innings, he added just 6 runs before being dismissed by Akash Deep. This controversy adds another layer to an already challenging match for Root. The incident underscores the importance of precise adherence to cricket laws and highlights the ongoing scrutiny faced by players and officials alike. As discussions continue, this event serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in ensuring fair play in cricket.